Al Pacino's 1985 disaster: why Revolution nearly ended his career
How a 1985 historical drama nearly destroyed Al Pacino's career and forced a four-year comeback.

This story has affiliate links. If you buy through them, Radazoid may earn a commission at no cost to you. How that works.
Revolution is a 1985 British historical drama directed by Hugh Hudson, written by Robert Dillon, and starring Al Pacino as Tom Dobb, a frontiersman caught up in the American Revolutionary War. Donald Sutherland and Nastassja Kinski co-star. The film became a financial catastrophe that marked a turning point in Pacino's career.
What went wrong?
Critics eviscerated Revolution on release. The consensus was brutal: the film was panned for its miscast lead, plodding pacing, and a script that couldn't justify its ambitious scope. The film was a critical disaster across the board.
Watch it: Revolution (1985) Blu-ray on Amazon (See the infamous flop that nearly ended Pacino's career—a fascinating piece of cinema history and a cautionary tale abou)
Pacino bore the brunt of the criticism. By the mid-1980s, after hits like Scarface (1983) and the Godfather films, audiences expected better. Revolution felt like a step backward—a prestige project that missed on every level. The film's poor performance played a key role in the collapse of Goldcrest Films, the production company that had invested heavily in it.
The four-year absence
After Revolution bombed, Pacino took a four-year hiatus from films. He didn't appear in another film until 1989, when he returned with Sea of Love—a cop thriller that proved audiences still wanted him. That comeback was successful and essentially reset his career trajectory.
For a star of Pacino's caliber, a four-year absence was almost unheard of. It signaled that Revolution had done real damage to his bankability and his confidence in choosing roles. In the industry, a failure of that magnitude can end careers. For Pacino, it was a near-death experience.
Why did it fail so badly?
Producer Irwin Winkler had wanted to make an American Revolution epic. He attached director Hugh Hudson to the project and had a script by Robert Dillon. Hudson even considered shooting it as a silent film at one point—a sign that nobody quite knew what they had.
The casting of Pacino as a frontier everyman didn't work. Audiences saw a Method actor in colonial drag in a drama that felt ponderous and stagey. The supporting cast—Sutherland, Kinski, Joan Plowright—couldn't save it. The battle scenes, filmed across English locations, looked unconvincing. Nothing clicked.
The aftermath
Goldcrest Films never recovered from the financial blow. For Pacino, the lesson was brutal: even a star can't carry a bad script, bad direction, and a bloated budget. When he returned in 1989, he was more selective and more aware that his choices mattered.
Revolution remains a relic of 1980s excess—a film that tried too hard and delivered too little. It's a footnote in Pacino's filmography, a stumble that nearly became a fall. But his comeback proved that one disaster, however public, doesn't have to define a career if you're willing to step away and come back stronger.
Quick answers
What was the plot of Revolution?
Pacino played Tom Dobb, a frontiersman in colonial New York who becomes caught up in the American Revolutionary War. The film followed his journey from reluctant soldier to patriot, spanning battles from Brooklyn Heights to Yorktown.
Why did critics hate it?
Critics called it a misguided effort with a miscast ensemble and ponderous script. Pacino was seen as wrong for the role, and the film's pacing and direction didn't work.
When did Pacino return to films after Revolution?
Pacino didn't make another film for four years. He returned in 1989 with Sea of Love, a cop thriller that was both a commercial and critical success.
Was this worth your time?












Sound off
Disagree all you want, swear if you have to (we'll #@$%! it out). No harassment, slurs, threats, spam or links. Comments are screened before they appear, and you'll get a daily heads-up when the conversation picks up. Your email is never shown.